新浪新闻

贫富差距和阶级分化:南加大学生的真实生活

微德国Germany

关注

来源:NYT教育频道

“我遇到这些有钱的孩子,他们有很多我无法理解的东西,做着我无法理解的事情。”南加州大学大二学生奥利弗·宾利说。 JENNA SCHOENEFELD FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

LOS ANGELES — Spring breaks in Bali, resort-style apartment buildings with rooftop pools and tanning beds and regular dinners out at Nobu, where a tab for four roommates could easily stretch into four digits。 This is life as a student at the University of Southern California。

洛杉矶——去巴厘岛休春假;住在带屋顶泳池、日光浴床的度假村风格公寓楼;时常去Nobu餐厅——那里四位室友吃一顿账单很容易就到四位数。这是南加州大学(University of Southern California)学生的生活。

This is also life as a U.S.C。 student: working an overnight shift to earn money for books, going hungry when the campus meal plan runs out and seething as friends presume that a $20 glass of wine is affordable。

以下同样也是南加大学生的生活:为挣书本费上夜班;因校园就餐计划用完而饿肚子;在朋友认定20美元一杯红酒不贵时感到恼火。

The divide between rich and poor students could hardly be more vivid than it is at U.S.C。, where the children of celebrities and real estate moguls study alongside the children of nannies and dishwashers。

在南加大,学生之间的贫富差距体现得再明显不过了。在这里,名人、地产大亨的子女与保姆、洗碗工的子女同窗伴读。

Now, the college admissions bribery scheme, which has ensnared dozens of wealthy parents accused of bribing their children’s way into U.S.C。, has brought renewed attention to class divides on campus — and how different the student experience can be depending on the size of the bank account。

现在,大学招生舞弊案——涉案的数十名富裕的父母被控把子女“买”进南加大——令校园里的阶级分化以及家境决定学生体验的不同,再度受到关注。

“U.S.C。 tries to paint the campus as this beautiful place to enjoy and relish in abundance,” said Oliver Bentley, a sophomore who is among the first in his family to attend college。 “There’s this idea that once you enter U.S.C。, you’re all on the same playing field。 That in and of itself is a lie。 I have met these rich kids who have so much that I can’t comprehend, doing things that I can’t fathom。”

“南加大试图把校园描绘为一个可以尽情享受与品味富足的地方,”大二学生奥利弗·宾利(Oliver Bentley)说,他是家里的第一个大学生。“存在这样一种观念,就是一旦进入南加大,大家就在同一个赛场上。这本身就是个谎言。我遇到这些有钱的孩子,他们有很多我无法理解的东西,做着我无法理解的事情。”

Interviews with students on campus from across the economic spectrum show how difficult it is to navigate a university that tries to be a home for all。 After decades of attracting some of Los Angeles’s wealthiest families, U.S.C。 has aggressively recruited and enrolled students who could never afford the roughly $57,000 annual tuition。

对校园里各经济层级的学生所作采访显示,在一所试图容纳各类学生的大学就读并非易事。几十年来,这所大学吸引了洛杉矶一些最富有家庭的子女,现在,它积极招收那些无法负担每年约57000美元学费的学生。

But the reality for many is a microcosm of the economic disparities of the city the campus calls home — and as in the rest of Los Angeles, the vast majority feel ill-equipped to bridge the divide。

但对许多人来说,现实就是,这座校园是所在城市经济差异的缩影。像洛杉矶的其他地方一样,绝大多数人都觉得根本无法弥合这道鸿沟。

The university has made attracting students from all backgrounds a priority and by almost any measure, its recruitment efforts have been a resounding success。 The academic credentials of incoming freshmen have steadily risen, and applications to the university are at an all-time high。 As U.S.C。 has fought to shed its reputation as a playground for the spoiled elite, officials have boasted about its racial and socio-economic diversity: More than a quarter of all students are from underrepresented minority groups, 14 percent of freshmen are the first in their families to attend college, and two out of three students receive financial assistance。 The college has one of the largest financial aid pools in the country — more than $350 million, an increase of nearly 80 percent over the last decade。

南加大把吸引不同背景的学生列为优先事项,并且从各个角度来看,它的招生工作都取得了巨大成功。入校新生的学术资质稳步上升,申请人数也处于历史高点。南加大一直在努力摆脱其作为被宠坏的精英游乐场的声誉,它目前种族和社会经济构成的多样性令校方官员感到自豪:四分之一以上的学生来自未获充分代表的少数群体,14%的新生是家里的第一个大学生,三分之二的学生获得经济补助。该校有全美最大的经济支助资金池——超过3.5亿美元,比十年前增加了近80%。

黑兰·马默说,过去四年在南加大,她外出享用昂贵的餐食很少会犹豫。 JENNA SCHOENEFELD FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

And yet, as the bribery cases have made clear, the campus remains a place of pervasive wealth, where celebrity, money and status are still a part of daily life。 This is the campus of choice for Dr。 Dre, who boasted last month about his daughter being admitted on her own merit, without mentioning that he had donated millions for a school building named in his honor。 Wealth is so closely associated with U.S.C。 that when a recent “Saturday Night Live” skit spoofed the admissions scandal, it opened with a shot of U.S.C。’s central library。

然而,正如贿赂案所表明的,这座校园仍是到处渗透着财富的地方,名人、金钱与地位仍是其日常生活的一部分。这座大学是Dr。 Dre(音乐人、嘻哈传奇人物——编注)的选择,他上月夸口说女儿凭自己的本事考上了这里,却没提及他给一栋以他本人命名的院系大楼捐了几百万美元。财富与南加大的关系如此密切,以至于不久前《周六夜现场》讽刺招生丑闻的小品里,开场镜头就是南加大的中央图书馆。

On the sun-streaked campus, students said conversations focused on a mix of envy and judgment for those with more。 Students of all backgrounds said they often silently worried that they were being judged by their peers — either for having too much or not enough。

在阳光照耀的校园里,学生们说谈话大多集中在对富有群体的羡慕和评判上。各种背景的学生都表示,他们常常暗自担心同伴正投来评判的眼光——要么是因为拥有太多,要么是不够多。

Mr。 Bentley was raised by a single mother in Menifee, a small working-class city about 80 miles east of Los Angeles。 When he arrived on campus, he expected to feel comfortable quickly, but instead said he was “completely alienated” because he did not have enough money。 Most of his friends now, he said, come from similar backgrounds, “lower middle class or just poor。”

奥利弗·宾利来自洛杉矶80英里外的工薪阶层小城门尼菲(Menifee),由单亲妈妈带大。当初来到这里时,他原本期望很快就能自在起来,结果却说他被“完全疏远”了,因为没有足够的钱。他说,现在他的大部分朋友都来自相似的背景,“中下阶层或者就是穷人”。

Undoubtedly, there are benefits to attending a private university with a $5.5 billion endowment: gleaming new buildings, access to premier technology, smaller classes。 And wealthy students are a fixture at elite colleges across the country — the challenges at U.S.C。 are similar to issues faced by students at many top private universities。

毫无疑问,去一所拥有55亿美元捐赠基金的私立大学是有好处的:崭新的教学楼、能接触到一流技术、班级更小。富有的学生是全国精英大学的固定生源——南加州大学面临的挑战与许多顶尖私立大学的学生面临的问题类似。

“We know when low-income students get to these elite schools, they have a large problem with fit,” said Jessica Thompson, the director of policy and planning at the Institute for College Access & Success。 “These schools have built reputations in the world that they are operating to erase class lines, but they are actually sort of hardening the types of inequity they claim to eliminate。”

“我们知道,低收入家庭的学生进入这些精英学校时,他们面临很大的适应问题,”大学入学与成功研究所(Institute for College Access & Success)的政策与规划主任杰西卡·汤普森(Jessica Thompson)说。“这些学校在世界上建立了致力于消除阶级界线的声誉,但实际上,它们在某种程度上强化了声称要消除的不平等。”

But whether because of the students it attracts or because of its place in glittering Los Angeles, the campus exudes a kind of singular flashiness。 There are also signs that the university understands the buying power of students。 In the campus bookstore, one wall is filled with pricey Kiehl’s bath products and an Abercrombie & Fitch welcomes students in U.S.C。 Village, a $700 million residential and retail development opened by the university in 2017。

但无论是因为它所吸引的学生,还是因为它置身于光彩夺目的洛杉矶,校园里焕发出一种独特的光彩。还有迹象表明,学校很清楚学生的购买力。在校园书店里,一面墙全是昂贵的科颜氏(Kiehl’s)沐浴产品,南加州大学村是该校于2017年开放的住宅和零售开发项目,耗资7亿美元,村内有一家爱芙趣(Abercrombie & Fitch)店在迎接学生们。

Heran Mamo, who grew up in Portland as the only child of an epidemiologist and a sportswriter who both emigrated from Ethiopia, considers herself middle class。 In the last four years, she has seldom hesitated to go out for expensive meals and drinks。

赫兰·马默(Heran Mamo)在波特兰长大,是家中独女,父母是流行病学家和体育记者,都是来自埃塞俄比亚的移民。她认为自己是中产阶级。过去四年里,她几乎不会在出去吃大餐喝美酒的事情上纠结。

“There’s not a huge culture of saying no to spending,” said Ms。 Mamo, who will graduate this spring。 “You think ‘I deserve to treat myself,’ and you start fearing saying you can’t do something because you can’t afford it。”

“这里并不盛行拒绝消费的文化,”今年春天即将毕业的马默说。“你会想‘我理应善待自己’,然后你开始害怕说,你做不了某件事,只因为没钱。”

When she has turned down invitations because of money — bypassing a night out or a spring break in Hawaii — her friends have been understanding, Ms。 Mamo said。 Money is rarely spoken about explicitly, she added, and “people don’t really acknowledge when they’re really wealthy, you usually only find out after a while。”

马默说,当她因为钱的问题而拒绝邀请时——比如不在外面过夜,或者去夏威夷度春假——朋友们都能理解她。他们很少明确地谈钱,她还说,“当人们真的很富有时,他们并不会真地承认,往往过一段时间你才会发现。”

居住着约3600名学生的Lorenzo公寓楼素有全美最大——也最奢华的私有学生住宅楼群之称。 JENNA SCHOENEFELD FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Some of the most overt signs of wealth are in the campus fraternity and sorority system, where dues often reach in the thousands of dollars, even before the extra money for exclusive formal parties and the wardrobes required to attend them。 (One recent trend: Golden Goose sneakers, which cost about $500 a pair。)

大学联谊会和女生联谊会是最明显的财富标志之一,会费往往高达数千美元,甚至还不包括专门的正式派对和参加派对置装所需的额外费用。(最近流行的是金鹅运动鞋[Golden Goose],每双售价约500美元。)

The impact of family income goes beyond campus social life。 Wealthier students can easily turn to private tutors when they are struggling in class, and often have built-in access to their parents’ networks, which they can turn to for jobs and internships。

家庭收入的影响不仅限于校园社交。较富裕的学生在课堂上遇到困难时,可以很容易地求助于私人教师,而且在找工作和实习时,往往可以利用父母的人脉。

“People know they want to be rich,” Ms。 Mamo said。 “That’s the goal in mind, it’s just a question of how realistic that is。”

“人们知道自己想致富,”马默说。“这就是我们心里的目标,问题是该怎么实现这个目标。”

Growing up in Cohasset, Mass。, a wealthy coastal community south of Boston, Dan Toomey knew he was well off。 “You would be naïve to think you weren’t born into privilege there,” he said。 And he knew U.S.C。 had a reputation as a haven for spoiled children, but he has seen little evidence of that。

丹·图米(Dan Toomey)在马萨诸塞州的科哈塞特长大,那是波士顿南部一个富裕的滨海社区,他知道自己很富有,“如果你觉得自己不是生来就享有特权,那就太天真了,”他说。他知道南加州大学是被宠坏孩子的安乐窝,但他几乎没有看到这方面的证据。

“Everyone is always pursuing different things, doing all kinds of projects,” he said。 “We’ve all been told over and over again: you’re going to be poor, you’re never going to make as much as your parents, you’re going to need to move back in with them。 So we’re much more financially sensitive than perhaps other generations。”

“每个人都在追求不同的东西,做各种各样的项目,”他说。“我们被反复告知:你会变穷,你挣的钱永远不会像父母那么多,最后你得搬回去和他们一起住。所以我们可能比其他几代人在经济上更敏感。”

作者:Jennifer Medina

翻译:李建芳、晋其角

加载中...